In the hustle and bustle of the season, we would expect no less in a bull, bull, bull world. Our experience matches our expectations. Such is not the case with the financial markets.
While we are a couple weeks away from posting final 2022 results, the bull, bull, bull world has failed to deliver results. Depending on your yardstick of choice, you might categorize the results as poor, bad, or even horrific. Yet we cannot blame investors for not trying: the rally in both stocks and bonds from October to early December appeared to have legs…until it did not.
There is a reason for this expectation/performance mismatch, and it is not inflation. The reason is the bull market is over. And while stock investors may continue to believe they have seen this movie before, bond investors are surprisingly acting the same way.
Nowhere is the bull, bull, bull world more apparent than in the world of bonds. One example is in spreads. In writing about the treasury market, Jeff Sommer at the New York Times says “this has been an awful year for U.S. bonds — so bad that 2022 may end up as the worst calendar year in history.” Maybe that explains how Idaho Housing sold its 4.384% taxable municipal at 11 basis points below treasury yields (higher priced) last week (per Bloomberg). The bond is not a treasury! Idaho Housing bonds due six months later sold to the spread of seven basis points. Yeehaw! A lack of spread to treasuries is very bull, bull, bull.
(more…)